09/03/2025
FINALLY, I managed to get the bike registered in RI. I took two drives down to the White Plains NY DMV (2.5 hours each way) to try and get the previous owner's sales tax paid so I could prove ownership that way, but that turned out to be a dead end.
I spent $70 on a consultation with a guy who specializes in sorting difficult titles and he suggested going for a court-ordered title - but that would be more time, money and hassle. Then a friend suggested selling the bike to my daughter who lives in NH. You can register an older bike there with just a VIN check and a bill of sale. Long story short, that's what we did and once she had it registered in NH, she could sell it back to me so I was able to register in RI.
That wasn't quite the end of the story though. The RI DMV initially refused to register the bike because it doesn't have a 17-digit VIN. They told me I would need to contact the manufacturer to have them issue a new VIN. When I explained that BSA went out of business in 1971, the girl behind the counter shrugged. I'd need to speak with Andy in Enforcement, but he was at the beach that day. Eventually I tracked down Andy, who turned out to be a great guy, even although he's an Indian rider. He set up a meeting for me, checked out the paperwork, and got the registration done.
Moral of the story: if you want to restore old bikes with slightly iffy paperwork, best move to New Hampshire.